Can I screen damp soil?

Punchplate vs Mesh Screens: What’s the Difference, and Which Should You Choose?

At Spitfire Engineering, one of the questions we’re often asked is: Should I use punchplate or mesh screens on my deck screen or trommel drum? Both options have their place in recycling and material separation, but the right choice depends on your material, throughput, and the results you want. Here’s a clear breakdown of the differences, pros, cons, and typical applications for each.

What’s the Difference?

Punchplate: A solid steel sheet with holes (round, square, or slotted) punched through it. Thickness and hole size can be customised. Extremely robust.
Mesh Screen: Made from woven or welded wire, forming a grid of square or rectangular openings. Available in a wide range of aperture sizes and wire thicknesses.

Punchplate: Pros, Cons, and Applications

Pros:
Extremely durable — handles heavy, abrasive, or sharp materials without wearing out quickly.
Resistant to impact and tearing — ideal for tough, high-volume environments.
Easy to clean, less prone to blinding with wet or sticky material.
Cons:
Heavier than mesh, which can add weight to moving parts like trommel drums.
Limited in how fine the apertures can be — usually not suitable for very small (fine) separations.
Less open area compared to mesh, so sometimes lower throughput for a given size.
Typical Uses:
Scalping screens — removing large rocks or oversize material before finer screening.
Primary screening of construction & demolition waste, hardcore, or scrap metal.
Applications where screen life and resistance to damage are critical.

Mesh Screen: Pros, Cons, and Applications

Pros:
Available in a huge range of aperture sizes for fine or precise separations.
Lighter than punchplate — reduces weight on moving equipment.
Higher open area allows for greater throughput and better screening efficiency.
Cost-effective for many applications.
Cons:
Less durable — can wear out faster with abrasive or sharp materials.
More prone to blinding or clogging with wet or sticky materials.
Can be damaged by impact or heavy objects.
Typical Uses:
Soil, compost, and fine aggregate screening where precision is needed.
Recycling of light, non-abrasive materials.
Secondary or finishing screens after initial scalping.

Which Should You Choose?

If you’re dealing with large, heavy, or abrasive materials — or need your screen to last as long as possible — punchplate is usually the way to go. For finer separations, higher throughput, or when working with lighter materials, mesh screens are often the better fit.

Examples:

Punchplate: Screening demolition rubble at a recycling yard; removing large stones from raw aggregate; protecting finer mesh screens from damage in a two-stage setup.
Mesh Screen: Producing topsoil for landscaping; compost screening at a green waste facility; separating fines from sand and gravel.